THE POWER RANK

  • About
    • About The Power Rank
    • Start Here
    • Contact
  • Predictions
    • Games
    • March Madness
  • Content
    • Must Read
    • Blog
    • Podcast
    • March Madness Book
  • Rankings
    • NFL
    • College Football
    • MLB
    • Cluster Luck
    • College Basketball
    • NBA
    • CFB yards per play
    • World Soccer/Football
  • Members
    • My Account
    • Login
    • Become a member
    • COVID-19 Policy
  • Log in

Stanford’s new quarterback, and other thoughts on the spring football game

By Dr. Ed Feng Leave a Comment

Stanford finished 7th in The Power Rank at the end of last season, a touch behind Wisconsin (7) but more than a point better than Oklahoma (8). But how will the Cardinal fare next season without quarterback Andrew Luck, a top pick in this month’s NFL draft? The spring football game held this past Saturday gave a definitive answer.

Brett Nottingham is a better quarterback than Josh Nunes All the headlines stated that neither of these quarterbacks distinguished themselves. Coach David Shaw said the competition will continue into the fall. But Nottingham was the better quarterback in the spring game. He completed 12 of 19 passes (63%) while Nunes struggled for 11 of 29 (38%). Moreover, when the defense was dominating in the second half, a 20 plus yard Nottingham completion was the only bright spot for the offense. Nunes threw way too many balls that weren’t even close to their target. Even on his long touchdown pass to Ty Montgomery, he missed the window in which his receiver was open. Nunes threw a few moments later, making Montgomery grab the ball between two defenders. It would be shocking if Nottingham isn’t the starter.

The defense was awesome, I think… At one point in the second half, outside linebackers Chase Thomas and Trent Murphy were seemingly in the backfield on every play. The penetration was so irritating that it led to a shoving match with the quarterback at the end of one play. The two linebackers weren’t on the field later in the half when the offense started moving the ball. So is the Cardinal defense “definitely the top defense in the Pac-12, if not the nation,” as Thomas told the San Francisco chronicle when he decided to forego the NFL draft? It’s not out of the question after Saturday. The defense finished 19th in the nation for scoring defense after we adjust for strength of schedule and returns 8 starters. Or was Thomas just licking his chops because Jonathan Martin, the Stanford offensive tackle who will likely be a first round NFL draft pick this year, wasn’t lined up opposed to him? Either way, Cardinal fans are praying that Thomas figures out how to read the option before the Oregon game this year.

The big fellas up front. Entering the spring game last year, the offensive line had to replace 3 senior starters. However, the remaining starters, David DeCastro and Jonathan Martin, were top NFL prospects, and the offense line powered a punishing ground game that gained more than 10 yards per attempt against Washington. But DeCastro and Martin are gone, and their buddies got roughed up on Saturday. The defense pressured on the quarterback all day, a factor in the poor completion rate of Nunes. With a host of top offensive line recruits arriving on campus this fall, could the Cardinal line look much different on September 1 than it did this past Saturday?

Agree? Think Nunes should be the starter? Please leave us a comment.

Filed Under: College Football, College Football 2012, Stanford Cardinal

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Predictions from Ed Feng

I use my Stanford Ph.D. in applied math to make football and March Madness predictions.

To get a sample of my best American football predictions and March Madness cheat sheet, sign up for my free email newsletter.

Enter your email and click on "Sign up now!"

Popular Articles

  • How to predict interceptions in the NFL
  • The ultimate guide to predictive college basketball analytics
  • Accurate football predictions with linear regression
  • The surprising truth about passing and rushing in the NFL
  • Football analytics resource guide
  • The Reason You Can’t Avoid The Curse of Small Sample Size
  • The essential guide to predictive CFB rankings
  • How computer rankings make you smarter about sports
  • How to win your college football bowl pool
  • Do you make these 3 mistakes with college football statistics?
  • How to win your NCAA tournament pool
  • The Top 10 Things to Know About The Power Rank’s Methods
  • 5 insights from academic research on predicting world soccer/football matches

Recent Articles

  • Podcast: Drew Dinsick on Predicting NFL Conference Championship Games
  • Members: Football analysis for NFL Conference Championship, 2020 season
  • Podcast: Chris Andrews on Predicting the NFL Divisional Playoff
  • Members: Football analysis for NFL Divisional Playoff, January 16-17, 2021
  • Podcast: Fabian Sommer on Predicting the NFL Wild Card Playoff

© 2021 The Power Rank Inc., All rights reserved.

About, Terms of Use, Privacy Policy

Get a sample of my best football predictions

While I usually save my best predictions for paying members of the site, I offer a sample in my weekly email newsletter.


To get this service, sign up for my free email newsletter.


Enter your email and click on "Sign up now!"

No thanks, I'll make predictions without data and analytics.

{"cookieName":"wBounce","isAggressive":false,"isSitewide":true,"hesitation":"","openAnimation":false,"exitAnimation":false,"timer":"","sensitivity":"","cookieExpire":"","cookieDomain":"","autoFire":"","isAnalyticsEnabled":true}
  • About
    • About The Power Rank
    • Start Here
    • Contact
  • Predictions
    • Games
    • March Madness
  • Content
    • Must Read
    • Blog
    • Podcast
    • March Madness Book
  • Rankings
    • NFL
    • College Football
    • MLB
    • Cluster Luck
    • College Basketball
    • NBA
    • CFB yards per play
    • World Soccer/Football
  • Members
    • My Account
    • Login
    • Become a member
    • COVID-19 Policy