THE POWER RANK

  • About
    • About The Power Rank
    • Start Here
    • Contact
  • Predictions
    • Games
    • March Madness
  • Content
    • Must Read
    • Blog
    • Podcast
    • March Madness Book
  • Rankings
    • NFL
    • College Football
    • MLB
    • Cluster Luck
    • College Basketball
    • NBA
    • CFB yards per play
    • World Soccer/Football
  • Members
    • My Account
    • Login
    • Become a member
    • COVID-19 Policy
  • Log in

NCAA is meeting with quants to make tournament selection process better

By Dr. Ed Feng Leave a Comment

On Friday, January 20th, 2017, hell will freeze over, and the NCAA will meet with analytics guys like Ben Alamar, Jeff Sagarin and Ken Pomeroy. The conversation will revolve around making the tournament selection process better.

You can read about it here, but two points stand out for me.

First, they say the following about the RPI rankings the committee currently uses.

An even more powerful microscope to go with the time-honored RPI.

Time-honored my ass. The RPI is stupid for two reasons:

  • It lacks a solid mathematical basis (compare it with the least squares rankings that Pomeroy uses)
  • It uses wins and losses instead of margin of victory in its calculations

I discuss both of these issues in relation to college football here. Hence, RPI fails as a predictor for how teams fare in the tournament.

The NCAA should eliminate RPI from the selection process.

Second, Jim Schaus, the athletic director at Ohio State and committee member, said this:

I’m going to have to strap on in the meetings to stay up with all the calculus that’s going to be discussed, but I’m excited about it.

Calculus is so overrated in our society.

You want to hang with the quants, Schaus? Then let’s talk probability, or that no analytics ever says a team will beat another team with 100% certainty.

Want to get fancy, Schaus? Then let’s dig into linear algebra so you can understand the least squares method used in adjusting for strength of schedule.

I’m all for learning calculus. It’s just not as useful in sports analytics as probability and linear algebra.

Filed Under: March Madness, NCAA Men's Basketball Tournament, Sports Analytics

Predictions from Ed Feng

I use my Stanford Ph.D. in applied math to make football and March Madness predictions.

To get a sample of my best American football predictions and March Madness cheat sheet, sign up for my free email newsletter.

Enter your email and click on "Sign up now!"

Popular Articles

  • How to predict interceptions in the NFL
  • The ultimate guide to predictive college basketball analytics
  • Accurate football predictions with linear regression
  • The surprising truth about passing and rushing in the NFL
  • Football analytics resource guide
  • The Reason You Can’t Avoid The Curse of Small Sample Size
  • The essential guide to predictive CFB rankings
  • How computer rankings make you smarter about sports
  • How to win your college football bowl pool
  • Do you make these 3 mistakes with college football statistics?
  • How to win your NCAA tournament pool
  • The Top 10 Things to Know About The Power Rank’s Methods
  • 5 insights from academic research on predicting world soccer/football matches

Recent Articles

  • Podcast: Drew Dinsick on Predicting NFL Conference Championship Games
  • Members: Football analysis for NFL Conference Championship, 2020 season
  • Podcast: Chris Andrews on Predicting the NFL Divisional Playoff
  • Members: Football analysis for NFL Divisional Playoff, January 16-17, 2021
  • Podcast: Fabian Sommer on Predicting the NFL Wild Card Playoff

© 2021 The Power Rank Inc., All rights reserved.

About, Terms of Use, Privacy Policy

Get a sample of my best football predictions

While I usually save my best predictions for paying members of the site, I offer a sample in my weekly email newsletter.


To get this service, sign up for my free email newsletter.


Enter your email and click on "Sign up now!"

No thanks, I'll make predictions without data and analytics.

{"cookieName":"wBounce","isAggressive":false,"isSitewide":true,"hesitation":"","openAnimation":false,"exitAnimation":false,"timer":"","sensitivity":"","cookieExpire":"","cookieDomain":"","autoFire":"","isAnalyticsEnabled":true}
  • About
    • About The Power Rank
    • Start Here
    • Contact
  • Predictions
    • Games
    • March Madness
  • Content
    • Must Read
    • Blog
    • Podcast
    • March Madness Book
  • Rankings
    • NFL
    • College Football
    • MLB
    • Cluster Luck
    • College Basketball
    • NBA
    • CFB yards per play
    • World Soccer/Football
  • Members
    • My Account
    • Login
    • Become a member
    • COVID-19 Policy