THE POWER RANK

  • About
    • About The Power Rank
    • Start Here
    • Contact
  • Predictions
    • Games
    • March Madness
  • Content
    • Must Read
    • Blog
    • Podcast
    • The Craft of Sports Betting Professionals
    • March Madness Book
  • Rankings
    • World Soccer/Football
    • College Basketball
    • College Football
    • NFL
    • NFL passing success rate
    • MLB
    • Cluster Luck
  • Members
    • My Account
    • Login
    • Become a member
  • Log in

Are the NFL Replacement Referees Giving More of a Home Advantage?

By Dr. Ed Feng Leave a Comment

Are the replacement referees giving an addition home advantage in the NFL?Are you mad at the NFL’s replacement referees? These scabs just gifted a win to Seattle over a deserving Green Bay team on Monday Night Football. It’s so infuriating that union busting politicians have come out in favor of the NFL referees union.

We know referees favor the home team. In the book Scorecasting, Toby Moskovitz and Jon Wertheim did extensive research on the role of referees in home field advantage. For example, the winning percentage for home NFL teams went down after the NFL started using instant replay. More plays were overturned for the road team.

How much more of an advantage are the replacement referees giving the home team?

This season, the home team has won 64.6% of NFL games this season. This is higher than the 57.1% from the 1999 through 2011 seasons, the modern era of instant replay in the NFL. However, we don’t know this year’s home winning percentage with much precision because there have only been 48 games. The true percentage could be higher or lower than 64.6%. We can only estimate the distribution of this percentage, which is a bell shaped curve with a standard deviation of 7%. See the figure above. Note that there’s even uncertainly in the home advantage estimate over 13 years of regular season games.

One can show there’s a 85.6% probability the replacement referees are giving the home team a greater edge than the usual referees. While high, this probability is not greater than the 95% used in medical research to validate a result. One can also analyze the margin of victory for the home team, using 3.48 points this year compared with the 2.57 from 1999 through 2011. Then it’s only 68.3% certain the replacement referees are giving a greater home advantage than the normal referees. This is roughly consistent with the findings of Brian Burke at Advanced NFL Statistics.

The data points to an extra home field advantage. But the results aren’t strong enough to publish in a scientific journal. Yet. We’ll keep you updated.

Filed Under: Football Analytics, National Football League

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Data driven betting information

Valuable. Concise. Entertaining.

To sign up for The Power Rank's email newsletter, enter your best email and click on "Sign up now!"

Popular Articles

  • How to predict interceptions in the NFL
  • 5 insights from academic research on predicting world soccer/football matches
  • How to win your NCAA tournament pool
  • The ultimate guide to predictive college basketball analytics
  • Accurate football predictions with linear regression
  • The surprising truth about passing and rushing in the NFL
  • Football analytics resource guide
  • The Reason You Can’t Avoid The Curse of Small Sample Size
  • The essential guide to predictive CFB rankings
  • How computer rankings make you smarter about sports
  • How to win your college football bowl pool
  • Do you make these 3 mistakes with college football statistics?
  • The Top 10 Things to Know About The Power Rank’s Methods

Recent Articles

  • Podcast: Hitman on NFL betting, Super Bowl LVII
  • Members: Super Bowl game and prop analysis
  • 7-Nugget Saturday, January 28, 2023
  • Cincinnati at Kansas City, AFC Conference Championship Game
  • Podcast: Dr. Eric Eager on the NFL Conference Championships

© 2023 The Power Rank Inc., All rights reserved.

About, Terms of Use, Privacy Policy

Smarter sports betting in less than 5 minutes

Valuable. Concise. Entertaining.


These are the goals with every correspondence, which cover bets on the NFL and college football.


To sign up for The Power Rank's free email newsletter, enter your best email and click on "Sign up now!"


No thanks, I'll make my predictions without data and analytics.

{"cookieName":"wBounce","isAggressive":false,"isSitewide":true,"hesitation":"","openAnimation":false,"exitAnimation":false,"timer":"","sensitivity":"","cookieExpire":"","cookieDomain":"","autoFire":"","isAnalyticsEnabled":true}
  • About
    • About The Power Rank
    • Start Here
    • Contact
  • Predictions
    • Games
    • March Madness
  • Content
    • Must Read
    • Blog
    • Podcast
    • The Craft of Sports Betting Professionals
    • March Madness Book
  • Rankings
    • World Soccer/Football
    • College Basketball
    • College Football
    • NFL
    • NFL passing success rate
    • MLB
    • Cluster Luck
  • Members
    • My Account
    • Login
    • Become a member